ClaroscuroEl sombrerero con diagnóstico

An essay on pride and self-love in the culture of blocking

· 11 min read · Translated from the Spanish original. Read the Spanish original

Share
RSS

I. Four taps

Blocking someone takes four taps, and I've counted them: you open their profile, pull up the menu, pick the option and confirm. In the whole business there's only one question, and the phone asks it, wanting to know if you're sure. You tell it yes, and job done. Nobody asks the blocked person a damned thing. They'll keep writing to a brick wall for days, until they notice the photo has disappeared and their last message has been sitting there for a week with a single tick, and then they'll figure out all by themselves, like a detective without a client, that they've been kicked out of somewhere.

The thing has slipped into everyday habits with astonishing ease. "I've blocked him" is said nowadays in the same tone as "I've taken the bins out", and it works for everything: for the bore who won't drop it, for the bloke who disagreed with you in a group chat, and for the one who just made you uncomfortable. The guy who threatens you and the guy who bores you go into the exact same bag. That's where the trap is, and it's pure arithmetic: kicking someone out of your life to their face means a proper awkward row, and doing it on your phone takes four taps. When something comes that cheap, you end up using it for things you need and things you don't, confusing self-defence with saving yourself a conversation.

You think you're so bloody special that you grant yourself the luxury of blocking another person and binning them like a piece of single-use rubbish, something you'd never do face-to-face with someone of flesh and blood, taking refuge in relationships that are nothing more than interactions with disposable people, devoid of real depth or solid ties beyond mere shared interests.

II. Flesh and blood

Antonio Machado wrote a proverb back in 1924 that feels like it was tailor-made for smartphones: "The eye you see is not an eye because you see it; it is an eye because it sees you." The screen is packed with eyes of the first kind. There are faces, profile pics, looks straight into the camera, and not a single one is looking at you. That's why blocking is so easy to live with: nobody sees you doing it, least of all the person concerned.

Try transferring that to a room. You're talking to someone, and mid-sentence you get up without a word, walk out the door, and for years, whenever you bump into them in the street, you pretend they don't exist. Where I come from, that's always been called being a coward or a rude bastard, depending on the neighbourhood. In person, breaking off with someone forces you to utter a sentence, however short, and stand there long enough to see their face when they hear it. That face is the price.

Psychologist John Suler named the phenomenon in 2004: the online disinhibition effect. It basically means that without witnesses and without a pair of eyes in front of us, the brakes that living in society put on us just snap. Usually, disinhibition makes a lot of noise—flashing insults and ALL CAPS. Blocking is its mute variety, and for that very reason the most perfect one, because you don't even have to show your face to withdraw it.

III. Above

Pride—or soberbia in Spanish—comes from the Latin superbia, and superbia from super, "above". The proud man is the one who looks down from above, and the block-happy user has found a way to run a court from his sofa: he investigates the case, passes sentence and executes it with his thumb, all in one go and without hearing the defense. The courts, slow as they are, are far more polite. Even the worst defendant gets served a bit of paper.

Law even has a term for someone who doesn't show up: contumacy, or default—the legal status of a person summoned who fails to appear. The blocked person doesn't even qualify as contumacious. He doesn't know what he's accused of, doesn't know there was a trial, and doesn't know the only judge consulted was the opposing party, whom a phone asked if she was sure.

That leaves the word luxury, which is in the title for a reason. A luxury is spending what you have to spare, and someone who blocks at the drop of a hat thinks he has people to spare. He has reason to think so: social media dangles thousands of folk in front of him who watch his same shows and play his same games—a whole warehouse of spare parts. The miscalculation comes later, when he starts measuring his own worth by the amount of people he can afford to throw away.

In 1970, the economist Albert Hirschman explained that a disappointed customer has two paths. One is exit: he goes to the competition, no explanations given, a clean job that costs nothing. The other is voice: he complains, demands satisfaction, makes a stink, which is awkward and forces him to stick around. What makes someone choose voice over exit, Hirschman said, is loyalty.

Take that out of the supermarket and into human relations. Blocking is pure exit. It's treating a human being the way we treat a brand of yoghurt that let us down: you don't write them a letter, you grab a different pot from the fridge. Where there's no loyalty, there's no complaint, and where there's no complaint, you don't need words either.

IV. Disposable people

We also ought to look at who we're hanging around with. A huge slice of social life now takes place among strangers gathered around a hobby, a game or a TV series, knowing each other only by handle and opinion. We know what Bloggs thinks of the latest episode, but not whether he's got kids, if he's ill, or what he does when he turns off the screen. People you interact with daily while knowing sod all about anything that matters.

Platforms have a technical term for this of unintended honesty: interactions. They count them, add them up and sell them. An interaction doesn't create a debt or obligate you to anything, and nobody in their right mind would say they have "interactions" with their brother. What is done in four taps is undone in another four.

Sociologist Zygmunt Bauman saw it coming at the turn of the century, when he wrote that we were swapping relationships for connections, and that the beauty of a connection is how easy it is to sever. The block button is the upgraded version of that, because on top of severing the link, it wipes the other person out of sight, as if they'd never existed at all.

On the other bank are real bonds, which are far less convenient. They take time, and over time all their flaws show up. For those people I propose the word unblockables: your brother, your mate of twenty years, all those whose number you can block, but not their existence, because on Christmas Eve they'll be sitting opposite you and you'll have to pass them the salt.

And whoever takes shelter among disposable people ends up learning the full lesson, which has two halves. If everyone else is disposable to me, I'm disposable to them. Out of that comes a very particular brand of arrogance, with pure bloody fear underneath: blocking first so you don't get blocked yourself.

V. Self-love

All of this usually gets slapped with a flattering label: self-love. You cut ties cleanly, no explanations, and call it loving yourself. Spanish, which is old and has seen it all, remembers what the phrase used to mean: when we say someone's amor propio has been wounded, everyone understands that their pride took a hit, and nobody assumes their emotional health has been damaged.

Rousseau had already separated the two back in 1755. He distinguished amour de soi-même, self-love, which is the natural instinct for self-preservation and doesn't need to put itself above anyone, from amour-propre, vanity or wounded pride, which springs from comparing oneself to others and lives on coming out on top. Super again. Any healthy animal has the first. The second is an invention of living in society, and it's bloody hard work.

Erich Fromm wrapped up the idea in The Art of Loving in 1956 with an observation that sounds back to front at first glance: the selfish person doesn't love himself too much, he loves himself too little. Someone who genuinely likes himself can handle being contradicted and can apologize without breaking a sweat. The arrogant bloke can't afford to, because what he's defending is an image, and any disagreement puts a crack in an image. That's what the button is for.

The final tally is primary-school math. "I'm done talking to you" is five words, counted. Blocking is four taps. It looks like the button only saves a bit of effort, but what it really saves is that fifth word, you, and along with it anything the other person might have had to say back.

Meme: a man in a dark suit looks at the camera, with the caption “Sorry for texting you back instantly my phone was in my hand and I’m mature and I actually like you”.

VI. Shield and throne

None of this changes the fact that everyone owns their own attention. Someone messaging you doesn't make you their debtor, and nobody is obliged to answer everyone who knocks on the door. But the right not to listen is one thing and the right to vanish without warning is another, and the second doesn't come bundled with the first.

There's a block that works as a shield, and that one I defend without reservation. It's the one put up against harassment, against threats, against the bugger who keeps pushing after a firm no. Lawyers would call it a response to an unlawful aggression, which is the prerequisite for self-defence, and what it protects is a person's safety. There, the button is doing what it was invented for.

And there's another block that acts as a throne. It's used instead of words, when what's in front of you isn't danger but embarrassment, shame, a conversation you're too lazy to have. What it protects is the ego of the person pressing it. It's worth reminding the throne-dwellers: discomfort is not an unlawful aggression, no matter how much it pisses you off.

To tell them apart, I have a home-brewed test. Imagine the person sitting opposite you in a room, and ask yourself if you could explain to their face why you don't want anything more to do with them. If you could tell them without flinching, calm and with good reason, it's a shield. If the scene makes you cringe or want to run for the hills, what you've got under your thumb is a throne.

VII. Looking at the ground

The opposite of pride has its own etymology, and it's a lovely one. Humility comes from the Latin humilitas, from humilis, and that from humus, the earth beneath our feet. Dante took it literally: in Canto X of Purgatorio, the proud purge their sin by walking bent double under massive rocks, faces pressed to the ground, forced at last to look at what was underneath them.

On that very terrace, the first one, a scene is carved into the wall for the penitents to see as they pass. Emperor Trajan is riding out to war on horseback, surrounded by his army, when a poor widow steps in front of him and grabs his bridle. Her son has been killed and she wants justice. The emperor tells her to wait until he gets back. She asks what happens if he doesn't come back. He replies that his successor will see justice done then, and the widow snaps back that the good someone else does is no good to the man who leaves his own undone. Trajan yields to the argument, stops the march, and deals with her.

Dante says the woman was "at the bridle" of the horse, and the word fits like a glove. The screen has taken away the brake of the other person's face—Suler's brake. In the Purgatorio relief, the bridle is held by hand by someone on foot and without a penny to her name, holding back the most powerful man of his age. She was the brake.

Trajan ruled over half the known world. He had an army waiting and a war ahead of him—two unbeatable excuses not to stop. He stopped to listen to a woman who could give him bugger all.

Works cited

  • Antonio Machado, "Proverbios y cantares", in Nuevas canciones (1924).
  • John Suler, "The Online Disinhibition Effect", CyberPsychology & Behavior, 7 (3), 2004.
  • Albert O. Hirschman, Exit, Voice, and Loyalty (1970).
  • Zygmunt Bauman, Liquid Love (2003).
  • Jean-Jacques Rousseau, Discourse on Inequality (1755), note XV.
  • Erich Fromm, The Art of Loving (1956).
  • Dante Alighieri, Purgatorio, Canto X.
Share this essay
RSS