I. Even if I were mad

The other day, in a social skills workshop, I came out with the sentence I am proudest of this autumn. We were going through the resources there are for those of us with a severe mental disorder, the day centre came up, and I said, with all the conviction in the world: "I wouldn't go to a day centre even if I were mad".
Even if I were mad. Said the madman. Some sentences refute themselves and you don't notice until you hear them out loud, and this one I topped off with its other half, in case any doubt was left: "I don't like colouring mandalas or doing group activities".
Before anyone takes offence, let me make clear what I am not saying. There are people for whom a day centre puts the week in order, lays a table with company at lunchtime and gives them a reason to leave the house, and for a lot of people leaving the house is precisely the medicine. The mandalas are not to blame for anything either. My problem with them is one of geography: to colour them you have to go where they are.
The mandala, besides, has a pedigree that doesn't usually get told in the workshops. It came into Western psychology by the hand of Carl Gustav Jung, who between 1918 and 1919 was posted to Château-d'Œx, in the Swiss Alps, as commandant of the zone for the British prisoners of war interned there. He says in his memoirs that every morning he sketched in a notebook a small circular drawing, a mandala, which seemed to him to correspond to his inner situation that day. Alone. In his notebook. In the mornings. The man who put the mandala on the map of the psyche drew his on his own while in command of a camp of internees, which is the most contrary thing to a group activity I can think of and rather close to what I have come here to ask for.
The question the mandala leaves is who the place where it gets coloured was designed for. My answer, after many years as a patient, is that mental health care is designed for the madman who leaves the house: the one with legs, transport, the inclination and the patience for the waiting room. For the one who doesn't go out, who tends to be the one who is worst, there is little. That is what this is about, and about the law it would take to turn it round.
II. Public transport, crowds, outside the home

As well as bipolar disorder I have agoraphobia, and agoraphobia is described by the World Health Organization in its classification of diseases, the ICD-11, under code 6B02: a marked and excessive fear of several situations from which escape might be difficult or in which help might not be available. And it gives examples. Using public transport. Being in crowds. Being outside the home alone, in shops, in theatres, standing in a queue. Now think about how you get to a day centre. You take the bus or the underground, which is public transport. You leave the house alone. You queue at reception. And once inside, you do a group activity, which for an agoraphobic is a crowd on first-name terms. The way to the resource is, point by point, the definition of the disorder. It is like putting the wheelchair ramp behind three steps.
In the same workshop they explained to us the programme for severe mental disorder, the one that gives direct access to the psychiatrist, and they were honest about the small print: you have to travel. There is no bad faith in this. For the system, the patient's home is the place the patient comes out of. That someone should go towards it strikes it as an eccentricity.
And yet it does exist. In the Community of Madrid there are thirty-eight Community Social Support Teams, each made up of a psychologist, a social worker and two educators, who work in the person's home and neighbourhood. Each team looks after some thirty people. Thirty-eight times thirty comes to about eleven hundred places, in a region of seven million inhabitants. Eleven hundred places of somebody coming to your house. For the rest, which is nearly everything, you go.
Going to the house, besides, has been invented and measured, though far away. In Western Lapland, in Finland, since 1987, the team at Keropudas hospital, in Tornio, has arranged the first meeting with the patient and their people within twenty-four hours of the first call, and wherever possible holds it at home. They call it Open Dialogue. In a 2006 study of forty-two people who had had a first psychotic episode, at five years 82% had no residual psychotic symptoms and 86% had gone back to studying or to a full-time job. And now the tongs, because this has to be picked up that way: the study is small, it did not draw lots to put anyone on one of two treatments as clinical trials are supposed to, and against the group the same team had treated just before, with the method still half built, no significant differences came out in those results. I am telling it from hearsay, from the papers, not from having lived it. Finnish miracles, none. The idea, on the other hand, anyone can understand: twenty-four hours, at your house.
III. The safety distance

In front of a psychiatrist I always do the same thing, which is the worst thing you can do, and in that same workshop I confessed it just as it is: "I tried to tell them my whole life in one go, because that's how I am, I start talking in a gush". On the other side of a gush like that the usual thing happens too, and I summed it up in a sentence I still stand by: "the more of a psychiatrist, the more safety distance, which is something I detest about psychiatrists".
Safety distance is an expression from the road, and the road has it defined with a precision psychiatry could only wish for. Spain's General Traffic Regulations, in article 54, order whoever drives behind another vehicle to leave between the two "a clear space that allows him to stop, in the event of sudden braking, without colliding with it". The analogy holds up better than it looks. The psychiatrist drives behind, at his own speed, and leaves a gap in case the one in front brakes hard, and in this trade we brake a lot and without indicating.
And the distance has to be given its best version, because it has one and it is serious. It was invented, before coldness came into it, by those who got too close. In 1986 a national survey of psychiatrists was published in the United States with the question nobody wanted to ask, and 7.1% of the men and 3.1% of the women who answered admitted to having had sexual contact with a patient. From that, and from things like it, come the boundaries of the profession, and rightly so. A psychiatric patient is among those who carry the fewest defences when they walk into a consulting room, and the rule that protects them from whoever oversteps the mark has earned its place. So far, the distance is right.
What it doesn't have is a dose. Michael Balint, a Hungarian psychoanalyst who in the 1950s gathered family doctors in London to talk about their patients, wrote in 1957 that the drug most often prescribed in a surgery is the doctor himself, and that there is no manual to say in what dose he should prescribe himself, how often or at what risk. Seventy years on, that manual is still unwritten.
What has been measured is that the dose matters. In 2006, three researchers went back to the data of a large trial by the United States National Institute of Mental Health in which, among other things, an antidepressant was compared with a placebo, both prescribed by psychiatrists, and asked how much weight the psychiatrist each patient happened to get carried in the result. On the Hamilton scale, the one used to measure depression, the psychiatrist explained 6.7% of the variation in outcomes, and the drug 5.9%. The psychiatrist's figure fell a whisker short of statistical significance, and I say so because if I don't, somebody else will. Their conclusion was that a good psychiatrist boosts the effect of the antidepressant and of the placebo as well. In other words, the doctor gets prescribed too, and prescribing him at a distance is prescribing him in a small dose.
And here the road analogy breaks, which is where it has to break. On the motorway, the one in front doesn't brake so that they catch up with him. In the consulting room, he does. When I start talking in a gush I am braking, of course, but so that the one behind can get to me.
IV. It isn't willpower

I have been told it many times, "if you're depressed, well, do a bit of exercise", and recently I answered what has to be answered: that being depressed "is what makes me unable to do exercise". Shortly before, I had already said it shorter: "it isn't willpower, you know?". And in that same conversation I asked for the only thing I really ask for, which is little and is a huge amount: "I only need the neurochemistry to be with me, like the Force".
The willpower of the laboratories has a history worth telling, because it deserves a frame. In 1998, Roy Baumeister and his team sat sixty-seven students in front of a plate of freshly baked chocolate biscuits and a bowl of radishes. Some were allowed to eat biscuits. Others were told to eat radishes and not to touch the biscuits. Then they were set to solve some puzzles that had no solution, and the researchers measured how long they held out before giving up. The radish group gave up at around eight minutes. The biscuit group held out for about nineteen. Out of that came one of the most cited theories in the psychology of those years: willpower is a muscle that tires with use, a tank that runs down.
Guess what happened when they repeated it. In 2016, twenty-three laboratories in several countries tested the effect with a single protocol, registered before starting, with 2,141 participants, and the depletion of willpower came out with a size of 0.04, which in statistics is the closest thing to zero you can write without writing zero. Baumeister maintains that the task was badly chosen, and to be fair the argument goes on. But the muscle we were sold did not turn up when twenty-three laboratories went looking for it at once. Not even willpower has willpower.
Psychology getting things wrong comes with the salary, which is why it repeats its experiments. What pisses me off is that the health system works as if the muscle existed and, on top of that, were in good shape. To be seen you have to ask for the appointment, remember it, pick up the phone, go, wait and come back. All of that is will, and the will is one of the first things a depression takes. Psychiatry even has a Greek word for it, abulia, which means "without will", and it writes it in the reports with the same hand that then hands out the appointment.
And who misses has been measured. In 2000, a British study followed, in North Camden, in London, randomly chosen patients of the psychiatric out-patient clinics, some who went to their appointments and some who didn't, and the conclusion was clean: those who miss are more unwell, cope worse with their lives and are more likely to lose contact with the clinic and to end up admitted. Missing a psychiatric appointment is a symptom, and the one who has it is precisely the one who most needs to come back. A symptom isn't cured by asking the symptom to pick up the phone.
V. Choosing your battles

Once, in an emotional intelligence workshop, I said it with the solemnity of someone who has read the Criminal Code diagonally: "insulting a person because of their state of health is a crime and it has to be reported". I was told that you have to choose your battles, because fighting wears you down. Weeks later, in another group, it was me saying: "I've reached a point in my life where I want to choose very carefully the battles I fight". I suspect I didn't remember where I had got it from. That has a name, cryptomnesia, which is remembering somebody else's idea in the belief that it has just occurred to you, and I practise it with the ease of a man who leaves a party in someone else's coat.
And now the measurement, which this time falls to me. My sentence from the workshop was false in law, or nearly. Since 1 July 2015 minor insults are no longer a crime in Spain, except within the family. A serious insult is, but it has to be held to be serious "in the public estimation", and it is only prosecuted if the offended party files a private prosecution, which is a complaint with a lawyer and a court representative, and almost always with an invoice. What I had in my head, the hate crime, exists, and asks for a good deal more than a stray insult in a queue. In other words, what I said so solemnly was, at best, an aspiration.
The figures say it in fewer words. In 2023 the police recorded in the whole of Spain ELEVEN hate crimes and incidents on grounds of illness, the same as in 2022. That figure measures something other than what it seems to: how many times somebody got up, went to a police station, told it and managed to get it written down. The times a sick person is insulted for being sick, nobody measures, and if anyone did, the figure would be short of zeros. To report it you also have to leave the house.
In the end, I chose. One of the battles I had open I withdrew myself, and in withdrawing it I found out something I didn't know: I didn't want to win. I wanted it to be on record. And for something to be on record you don't need to win a lawsuit, you need someone to write it down, which is exactly what there isn't at any of the counters in this essay.
VI. The mad, to the Ministry of Equality

One night, in a chat, I came out with another of mine: "they ought to put us mad people in the Ministry of Equality". I said it half as a joke and I mean it wholly in earnest, because the question underneath is a good one: whose are we? Health's when we are ill, Social Services' when they give us a disability percentage, and nobody's for the rest of the week.
The funny thing is that we are already a little bit inside, by the back door. Law 15/2022, which calls itself comprehensive, for equal treatment, put on the list of grounds on which nobody may be discriminated against "illness or health condition" and "genetic predisposition to suffer pathologies and disorders", and to defend it created an Independent Authority. The law is from July 2022. The president of the Authority was appointed in May 2025, on the proposal of the Minister for Equality. The statute that tells it how it has to work was approved on 22 July 2026, four years and ten days after the law. We now have a counter at Equality. It has taken as long to open as it takes to get a degree.
And it is not the only law that already exists. The General Health Act, of 1986, devotes to mental health a chapter of a single article, the 20th, which orders that care "shall be provided in the community setting, promoting care resources at out-patient level and the systems of partial hospitalisation and care at home". Care AT HOME. Nineteen eighty-six. Read it again. What I am asking for here the State already wrote forty years ago, verb included, and the verb is the problem: promoting obliges nobody to anything. It is the verb of the leaflets.
So the most serious objection to all this I put to myself before anyone else does: that there are already laws to spare and what is missing is complying with them. It is half right. In September 2021 Congress agreed to take up a general mental health bill, and in January 2024 another one had to be registered, which says a good deal about how the first one fared. Laws, strategies and plans, heaps of them. What they all lack is the verb to go. All the laws wait at the counter for the madman to arrive, with his number, his appointment and his willpower, and the madman who is worst is the one who doesn't arrive.
That same night I said it my way: "they depersonalise you, they dehumanise you, they infantilise you, they treat you like a case file, not like a human being". And here Latin gave me a surprise. Expediente, the Spanish word for a case file, comes from expedire, which in Latin is to free the feet from the snare: ex, out, and pes, pedis, the foot. Its opposite is impedire, to put the feet in the snare, which gives the Spanish for to impede and for impedido, a word the dictionary still uses for someone who cannot use one of their limbs. The case file, in its origin, is what unties you. What they do to me is the other thing.
VII. A law that rings the doorbell

"And I want a comprehensive law for people with severe mental disorder in Spain within a few years", I said that night. Within a few years, because one may be bipolar but one can count. And since I have been treated like a case file so many times, I am writing it as one, with its articles, so that it can be read in the language things are read in at the ministries.
Article one. To whoever cannot go, somebody goes. Care at home stops being something that is promoted and becomes a right with a deadline, counted in hours, as in Finnish Lapland since 1987, and with its line in the budget, because a right without money is a leaflet with a stamp on it.
Article two. Missing an appointment is a clinical fact. The first miss is not filed away, it triggers a call, because it has been measured that those who miss are the ones who are worst, and because to get them back a reminder by phone works, and nobody has shown that sending another letter with another appointment does.
Article three. What is done to a body that is tied down gets counted, published and explained. Today Spain has no state-level rule of its own for mechanical restraints, and when the Ministry of Health finally wanted to draw the map of those carried out in mental health, region by region, it invited six universities to do it and, when the deadline closed, not one of the six had put in a bid. What isn't counted hasn't happened, and to some of us it has happened.
Article four. No right in this law depends on the person concerned feeling up to it. A right that asks for willpower in order to be exercised is a competition.
Sole additional provision. Mandalas, voluntary.
And now look again at where I said the thing about the mandalas. In a group workshop. Over Zoom. From my house. The man who wouldn't do group activities even if he were mad has been in heaps of group sessions this autumn, all of them by video call. I didn't have a problem with the group. I had a problem with the door, and the day the group came to my house, I went in.
Let them treat me like an expediente, then. But in Latin.
Works cited
- World Health Organization, ICD-11, code 6B02 (agoraphobia).
- C. G. Jung and Aniela Jaffé, Memories, Dreams, Reflections (1962).
- Community of Madrid, Social Care Network for people with severe and enduring mental illness: Community Social Support Teams.
- Jaakko Seikkula and others, "Five-year experience of first-episode nonaffective psychosis in open-dialogue approach", Psychotherapy Research, 16, 2006.
- Royal Decree 1428/2003, General Traffic Regulations (Spain), article 54.
- Nanette Gartrell and others, "Psychiatrist-patient sexual contact: results of a national survey. I: Prevalence", American Journal of Psychiatry, 143, 1986.
- Michael Balint, The Doctor, His Patient and the Illness (1957).
- Kevin M. McKay, Zac E. Imel and Bruce E. Wampold, "Psychiatrist effects in the psychopharmacological treatment of depression", Journal of Affective Disorders, 92, 2006.
- Roy F. Baumeister and others, "Ego depletion: is the active self a limited resource?", Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 74, 1998.
- Martin S. Hagger and others, "A multilab preregistered replication of the ego-depletion effect", Perspectives on Psychological Science, 11, 2016.
- Helen Killaspy and others, "Prospective controlled study of psychiatric out-patient non-attendance", British Journal of Psychiatry, 176, 2000.
- Alex J. Mitchell and Thomas Selmes, "Why don't patients attend their appointments?", Advances in Psychiatric Treatment, 13, 2007.
- Organic Law 1/2015, reforming the Spanish Criminal Code, and Criminal Code, articles 208 and 215.
- Spanish Ministry of the Interior, Informe sobre la evolución de los delitos de odio en España (2023).
- Law 15/2022, comprehensive, for equal treatment and non-discrimination, article 2, and Royal Decree 606/2026, Statute of the Independent Authority for Equal Treatment and Non-Discrimination.
- Law 14/1986, General Health Act, article 20.
- General Mental Health bills, Spanish Congress of Deputies (2021 and 2024).
- The Objective, "Seis universidades plantan a Sanidad…", 12 August 2025.

